The context: church disposals in Scotland
The Church of Scotland (CoS), faced with rising costs and falling congregations, is in the process of selling a significant portion of its estate.
With the money raised, the Church plans to reinvest the money, repairing the fabric of their remaining assets and refocusing their mission where they could have the most impact. In doing so, they hoped to right the ship and strengthen the institution for years to come.
In 2009, the Historic Environment Advisory Council for Scotland (HEACS) published a report which suggested the Church of Scotland would have to dispose of 400 and 500 churches over 30 to 40 years.
In 2021 General Assembly, the Church of Scotland approved the Presbytery Mission Planning Act, beginning the process of rationalising the Church’s estate in earnest.
The Act stated that: (2.0.1) Each Presbytery shall be required to have an Approved Mission Plan in place in terms of this Act by 31 December 2022.
(2.1.2) In doing so the Presbytery will categorise each ecclesiastical building as either:-
(a) to be retained beyond the five years from the date of the Approved Mission Plan, or
(b) to be sold, let or otherwise disposed of by a specified date which is within five years from the date at which the ecclesiastical building is first categorised as (b).
Therefore, this first iteration of the PMP process, in theory, would be concluded by December 2027.
This process is now well underway, with 359 disposals of ecclesiastical buildings authorised by the General Trustees between May 2020 and April 2026.